Other Sex Offender News: State and National
Our Commenting Policy ---///--- Our Blog Tips
Court says UNCONSTITUTIONAL:Missouri
Voting Rights: Approved ---- Denied -///- Voting Problems
Facility Law Libraries --/-- Phone Restrictions
Showing posts with label CA-Death. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CA-Death. Show all posts

Patients Cry Out for Help


Every state has laws that prosecute folks for not getting necessary care for the people in their charge. Why are administrators of these facilities not subject to those laws?
9-2-17 California:

Coalinga State Hospital (CSH) is experiencing a current crisis like none other in its past. On August 17, 2017, staff for Assemblyman Joaquin Arambula informed the Director of this website, that he could not help the patients at the Hospital that he represents. Approximately 100 patients have died at CSH since 2005, over 20 are currently in the dying process, and dozens are committing passive suicide by refusing medical treatment for serious illnesses.

Hundreds of professional staff have fled the facility over the years due to working conditions, and there are few prospects to replace them. Patient Services area presently stretched past the breaking point and are so serious that monthly treatment team meetings have been cut back to quarterly.

Psychologists have double their prior caseloads, and some nurses are being told to work as psych techs, as some examples. Medical doctors are also responsible for as many as 200 patients, and the hospital is spiraling out of control.

There is also information that outside medical specialists/contractors have terminated their contracts to see patients due to not being paid on time. ..Continue..

Ex-Napa State patient charged with new hospital homicide


9-13-2013 California:

A former Napa State Hospital patient acquitted of murder in 2009 for the stabbing death of a fellow patient has been charged with murder for allegedly killing an inmate at Patton State Hospital in Southern California.

George Aaron Carver is charged with the beating death of 65-year-old Kenneth Taylor, according to the San Bernardino Police Department.

On Aug. 31, at about 11:40 a.m., Carver found Taylor alone in his room at Patton State Hospital, San Bernardino Police Sgt. Gary Robertson said this week.

Carver said he targeted Taylor and two others because he does not like child molesters, Robertson said.

Carver allegedly punched Taylor, knocking him to the ground before hitting him 15 to 20 times with his fists, elbow and feet, Robertson said. He stomped on Taylor’s head more than a dozen times before staff intervened, having been alerted by other inmates, he said.

Taylor died from his injuries six hours later at Loma Linda University Medical Center, Robertson said.

Carver has been charged with murder in San Benardino County Superior Court. He has pleaded not guilty, according to court records. Carver remains in custody at West Valley Detention Center in Rancho Cucamonga, Robertson said.

Now 41, Carver has been incarcerated on and off since the late 1980s for various crimes. He was placed at Napa State Hospital after he was found criminally insane in El Dorado County in December 2007 on an attempted murder charge, according to court records.

In March 2008, Carver allegedly used a hairbrush with a sharpened handle to stab to death a patient at Napa State Hospital, according to court records. Carver pleaded not guilty and not guilty by reason of insanity to murder.

His defense argued Carver did so in self-defense because the patient, David Wengell, had been bullying and intimidating him and other patients on the unit inside Napa State’s secured area, according to court records. Staff testified Wengell had been threatening, dangerous and psychotic, according to court records.

Napa County Superior Court Judge Diane Price dismissed the murder charge at the request of the defense; the jury found Carver not guilty of manslaughter in September 2009.

A spokesman for the California Department of State Hospitals declined to say how long Carver had been at Patton State Hospital, citing patients’ privacy laws.

Gary Van Camp, a deputy district attorney who prosecuted Carver in Napa, did not know Carver had been arrested in connection with another killing. But he was not surprised at what has happened at Patton State Hospital, he said.

“I think he’s a dangerous person,” Van Camp said this week. “I’m not surprised he re-offended.”

He believes the jury thought Carver had acted in self-defense in the Napa homicide. “I disagreed with their verdict,” he said.

Joseph Solga, the deputy public defender who defended Carver, said he did not know about the current case other than what he has read in news stories.

“I was saddened to learn that another patient had been killed,” Solga said. “Society has a moral obligation to make sure patients at psychiatric hospitals are safe. We're not doing that. California's state hospitals are very dangerous places,” he said, referring to the state psychiatric facilities.

The California Department of State Hospitals oversee three units in state prisons and five psychiatric hospitals, including Patton and Napa state hospitals. The recent Patton homicide is the only one reported this year in the facilities run by the Department of State Hospitals, according to the state agency.

“The safety and security of staff, patients and the public has always been one of the highest priorities for the Department of State Hospitals. We remain committed to the ongoing analysis of aggression-related issues in order to make modifications to policies and processes system-wide as needed,” spokesman Ralph MontaƱo said in an email. ..Source.. by KERANA TODOROV

Patient Killed June 24--By Coalinga State Hospital Officer?


If anyone is a witness to what occurred they need to contact local police via the police website; search for it on Google.

Healthgrades Rating: Dr Neubarth


9-10-2013 California:

This special episode covers the life & untimely death of Coalinga State Hospital resident Isidro "Cedro" Zavala Torres. This man, known by CSH residents as Cedro Zavala, was classified as an MDO or Mentally Disordered Offender. This means, in addition to a crime for which he likely served a prison term, Zavala was diagnosed w/ a serious mental illness.

According to witnesses, Cedro Zavala was violently attacked by approximately 10 CSH staff/Department of Police Services (DPS) Officers at the facility between 12-1pm on June 24, 2013. The incident began when Zavala, who is wheelchair-dependent, refused to go to a medical appointment. Then, the staff/DPS swarmed.

Zavala resisted the take down--efforts to forcibly remove him from his wheelchair & throw him to the ground. Apparently, Zavala tried to stop the overzealous/unnecessary attack by spitting at them. While his actions cannot be condoned, this must've been a scary situation for a newer CSH resident w/ serious physical & emotional concerns. His efforts backfired--the situation escalated.

Once on the ground, the most aggressive officer allegedly stood on the man's neck w/ his heavy steel-toed boot. Witnesses theorize Zavala's larynx was crushed by the blow. As he gasped for air, officers flung him back in his chair, threw a towel over his face & rushed him away. Isidro Zavala Torres, 30, was died a short time later.

Shockingly, the officer suspected of causing Zavala's death wasn't suspended. Later that day, he told concerned residents Zavala had died of a drug overdose. Worse yet, mainstream media have not addressed this serious incident to date.

Listen to this important show & tune in Monday for more on abuses at CSH which were swept under the rug - until now. ..Source.. by CSH News

Obit HERE

Civil Commitment Deaths Drawn from Other Sources


National:

The following deaths come from a list kept by "Gulag News" a source which tracks everything with respect to civil commitment issues in California.

It appears they publish a newspaper and the last page of that newspaper is an updated list of folks who have died while in civil commitment in either Coalinga (new institution) or Atascadero (old institution).

The Jan-Jun 2009 Newspaper shows the following 48 names and dates of deaths:
1998-00-00: Robert Cloverdance
1998-06-19: Carl Coleman
1999-00-00: Jim Davis
2000-01-23: Don Lockett (*)
2000-05-10: David Stansberry
2000-05-29: Charles Rogers
2001-06-02: Larry Gooddard (*)
2001-06-12: Ed Samradi
2001-07-27: Dean Danforth
2002-07-04: Craig Bauwens (*)
2002-10-10: Wayne Graybeal
2002-11-07: Donald Hughes (*)
2002-11-05: Lloyd Johnson (*)
2003-03-15: Robert Alpern
2003-03-15: Tim McClanahan (*)
2003-03-15: Patrick Brim
2003-08-14: Wayne Porter
2003-12-11: Cash O'Dowd (*)
2004-05-07: Elmer Bock
2004-08-23: Dave Goenick (*)
2004-12-04: Jose Vlahoitis
2004-12-13: Corwin Weltey
2005-01-30: Ross Washington (*)
2005-02-07: Richard Bishop (*)
2005-08-19: Alton Robinson (*)
2005-09-01: Robert Canfield (*)
2005-09-24: Jerry Sanchez (*)
2005-11-24: Gerald Brooks
2007-07-20: James Aceves
2007-11-08: Frank Valadao (*)
2008-02-16: Donovan Myrick
2008-03-30: Paul Rael (Murdered)
2008-06-11: Paul Pedersen (*)
2009-01-12: Kenneth Edmonton
2009-02-02: Jimmy Guthrie (*)
2009-02-04: Barry Blake (*)
2009-02-24: Charles Grecien (*)
2009-05-29: James Wallace (*)
2009-07-22: Jari Stevens (*)
2009-10-02: John Martinez (*)
2009-12-29: Delbert Smith (*)
2009-12-05: Ruben Garcia
2009-12-31: William Perryman (*)
2010-02-02: David Montgomery
2010-03-31: William Laughlin (*)
2010-08-23: Richard Garcia (*)
2010-09-23: Francis Hanson
2010-09-27: Steven Mendoza (*)
(*) Known Medical Issues.
The list was also confirmed by Tom Watson who keeps track as well.

eAdvocate



Chesbro resolution would honor those who died in state institutions
I doubt he realizes that, a couple of the institutions are civil commitment centers (in part).
2-25-2010 California:

SACRAMENTO – From the mid 1880s into the 1960s, an estimated 45,000 people with developmental disabilities who died in California institutions were buried in unmarked locations – many in mass graves.

The locations of their remains are unknown because identifying records have been lost, or their remains were moved.

First District Assemblymember Wesley Chesbro (D-North Coast) has introduced Assembly Concurrent Resolution (ACR) 123, which would establish the third Monday of September as a Remembrance Day to memorialize these Californians.

“The stigma of living with developmental and mental disabilities has begun to disappear in recent generations,” Chesbro said. “But not too long ago those with developmental and mental disabilities were institutionalized and treated as less than human.

Thousands who died in these institutions were never given proper burial and the location of their remains is still unknown. It is time we do something to restore their dignity.”

Some of the state institutions involved in this practice, which are still in operation and are now participating in the California Memorial Project, include Napa State Hospital, Atascadero State Hospital, Metropolitan State Hospital in Norwalk, Patton State Hospital in Patton, Fairview Developmental Center in Costa Mesa, Lanterman Developmental Center in Pomona, Porterville Developmental Center, Coalinga State Hospital, Salinas Valley Psychiatric Program, Vacaville Psychiatric Program and Sonoma Developmental Center in Eldridge. Other state institutions that have since closed include Mendocino State Hospital in Talmage, Agnews Developmental Center in San Jose, Camarillo State Hospital, DeWitt State Hospital in Auburn, Modesto State Hospital and Stockton State Hospital.

In 2003, as a member of the California State Senate, Chesbro authored legislation establishing the California Memorial Project, a partnership between the state departments of Mental Health and Developmental Services and the California Network of Mental Health Clients, Disability Rights California and People First California to locate and identify the remains of those who died in these institutions. The legislation was signed into law on the third Monday of September that year.

The California Memorial Project identifies the locations of remains, restores the cemeteries and graves where those who died in state institutions were buried, preserves the history of residents of institutions and documents the history of the movement in California.

“Some progress has been made since 2003, but there is still a lot more work to be done,” Chesbro said. ..Source.. Written by Lake County News reports

A Sexually Violent Predator Killed


This is a highly unusual case of committed mental health person who was forced to move, due to the influx of SVPs from the then NEW civil commitment laws, and as the result of that move this mental health patient died. Maybe this should be called a "Other Death."
4-1-1998 California:

Craig Black was housed at Atascadero State Hospital while wrestling with the effects of chronic schizophrenia. Mr. Black never actually met a deviant whose violent lust knew no bounds. He died because a sexually violent predator took his bed. For a moment last June, it seemed as if the Supreme Court decision in Kansas v. Hendricks would finally quell the years long debate surrounding how society should deal with sex offenders who had served their prison sentences. Justice Clarence Thomas, leading a court split five to four, decided that civil commitment of dangerous sex offenders after they had served their criminal sentences was not a problem, at least constitutionally. The ruling sparked a defiant shout from, among others, psychiatrists and patient advocacy groups. They wondered about the misuse of psychiatry and populations often resistant to treatment.

Politicians seem to be happiest with the sexually violent predator laws, since sponsors of the legislation draws the compelling, tough-on-crime publicity that translates into votes at election time. And, the voting public does not concern itself with mental health policy or whether sexually violent predators will get better under the state's protective umbrella, so long as the "fiends" are off the street, hopefully for good.

Nearly a year later, the prospect of thousands of people deemed to be sexually violent predators ("SVPs") filing state hospitals, sometimes housed amid more vulnerable patients, or diverting scarce mental health resources continues to be a huge problem for almost everyone else. Many psychiatrists, psychologists, public health officials, judges, lawyers, policy makers, advocacy groups, and not least of all those who have long resided in civil psychiatric facilities, fear that there is a disaster waiting to happen, all in the name of keeping society safe. What sort of disaster?

After 11 years at Camarillo State Hospital, Black, 54, had carved out a life for himself within the protective environs of its bucolic campus. Despite the illness that kept him in and out of mental hospitals for three decades, he had managed along the way to get through college and receive a masters degree in religion.

All of that changed when the state decided last year to close Camarillo to make way for another state university. According to Carla Jacobs, a Commissioner for Mental Health in Los Angeles County, forensic patients displaced by the large influx of SVPs at Atascadero were moved to other state hospitals. Civil commitment patients like Black were moved out of the state hospital system altogether. After doing so well for so long, Black arrived at a private institute for mental disorder ("IMD") in February; by May he was dead, a victim of a heart attack.

To Black's relatives, who bitterly complained about his three month deterioration to little avail, there is a more identifiable culprit. "Our 'Great State of California' killed him, as sure as if the gas chamber was used, by forcing him into hospitals of lesser care and concern," said Douglas Black, his brother and conservator. ..more.. by Michael Jonathan Grinfeld, J.D.

Former ASH Patient's Death Prompts Review


12-8-2005 California:

Atascadero State Hospital is reviewing the records of a convicted sex offender who died of cancer 10 months after leaving the facility. The review was spurred by the man's attorney, who questioned the quality of the medical treatment her client received. In the letter to ASH Executive Director Melvin Hunter dated Nov. 18, San Bernardino County Public Defender Pamela King asked why ASH doctors conducted a less effective test that never found the colon cancer that killed 69-year-old Eugene Costa in June.
According to King's letter, which directly quoted several doctors' notes in Costa's medical records, ASH physicians in March 2004 agreed that Costa showed textbook symptoms of colon cancer. They recommended a colonoscopy, a procedure by which specialists use a tiny camera threaded through a patient's intestine to check for tumors and other ailments. The colonoscopy, King said, was never performed. "Mr. Costa looked like death warmed over," she wrote. "He was always very slender, but at that point, he looked like a concentration camp victim."
Instead, King wrote, Costa's physicians administered a barium enema, a faster and less costly procedure with a lower success rate at identifying cancer. Doctors at Mike O'Callaghan Federal Hospital in Las Vegas, who called paralegal Cathy Honseler in San Bernardino after Costa was admitted, reportedly told Honseler that his life might have been prolonged. The specialist, she said, was "livid" that the colonoscopy was not performed.

ASH spokeswoman Barrie Hafler said hospital administrators are reviewing Costa's records. She said there is no link between the hospital's current psychiatric staffing deficiency and the performance of independent medical doctors such as those who examined and treated him. Costa, she said, was treated by members of the hospital's medical staff, which operates separately from the psychiatric workforce. The medical department is fully staffed with 11 full-time doctors, she said.

"It would be difficult to draw a correlation between staffing and the public defender's concerns," Hafler said. "But we will give (the letter) close attention." Hafler would not discuss the letter further but said Hunter is looking into its contents. ..more.. : by Stephen Curran, The Tribune

Civil Detainee's Death Comes Amid Allegations That Coalinga State Hospital Falls Dangerously Short In Medical Care


11-14-2007 California:

Coalinga State Hospital, California's two year old $388 million facility for confining sex offenders after serving their entire prison sentence, is coming under renewed fire in the wake of Thursday's death of patient Frank Valado (YouTube Video), age 45.

Valado collapsed while playing basketball with other Civil Detainees in the institution's gynmasium Thursday evening. Patients witnessing the incident said that Staff response to Valado's collapse was completely inadequate and that, effectively, he received little or no treatment after being stricken.

They reported that an officer present in the gymnasium refused to radio in an alarm, despite their requests that he do so, but instead simply left the room. A Patient got the attention of another officer by pounding on a gymnasium window looking out onto the main courtyard. That officer then radioed the alarm that brought other staff to the scene.

One Patient began performing CPR on Valado and others present confirm that Valado partially regained consciousness. Then, a number of staff entered the gym, including two women, at least one of whom, Kathy Bryant, is a Registered Nurse. Officers ordered Michael Cheeks, who had been administering assistance to Valado, to halt his efforts and, along with the other men in the gym, to get up against the wall.

Bryant was then heard to say "I'm not putting my mouth on that man's mouth!" an apparent reference to her unwillingness to perform mouth-to-mouth resuscitation on Valado.

Patients also report that the other (unidentified) woman at the scene was searching for an oxygen tank and mask but which she was unable to locate.

A crash cart was brought into the room but it was discovered that it did not include a defibrillator. Patients later stated that they knew that there was a defibrillator on the other side of an always locked door to the gym but staff made no attempt to retrieve it or any other. Throughout this, Valado remained unassisted on the floor.

The other patients were then ordered to leave the gym and a gurney was brought in and Valado was taken to the Medical unit. However, no doctors were on duty at the time so staff then called a doctor to drive to the facility. However, before the doctor arrived at C.S.H., Frank Valado died.

The "Watch Commander" reportedly ordered all police staff to remain for the next shift, even if it were their third continuous shift on duty. The Administration is said to have been seriously concerned for the possibility of Patient anger and unrest due to the poor response by the hospital in Valado's death.

Mike St. Martin, a Detainee Spokesperson who has actively sought to bring attention to what he sees as grossly negligent standards of medical care, said he was "unsurprised" by the lack of appropriate medical response by C.S.H. Staff, stating that, since the beginning, the Institution had demonstrated an utter disregard for the well-being of Patients in the facility. "The only thing about this place that says "hospital" is the sign out in front. But that sign also says 'No emergency services available'.

Well, they got that part right! We refer to this place as a 'hosprison', since that is its primary function, to act as a prison, while pretending to be a hospital. The medical department here is a ticking time bomb with irresponsible delays, incorrect treatment, poor training, and medical care grossly deficient for an aging population. One can only hope that more people don't have to die before sweeping changes can be made".

"I wrote to Attorney General Jerry Brown in April of this year detailing the terrible medical conditions here and, to date, I have not received a response from him or his staff".

Since Executive Director Norm Kramer assumed authority in September, Dr. Peter Bresler has stepped down as Chief Physician and Surgeon while remaining as a staff physician. Patients bitterly complained of their treatment by Bresler, with one saying he had been told by Bresler that treatment for his seriously distended hernia would be considered "cosmetic" and thus not surgery that he would approve. It has been alleged that he was fired from a previous job as a result of "dropping a baby".

Deficient medical care and rubber stamped clinical assessments were amongst some of the chief complaints leading to the still ongoing strike by Civil Detainees, now in its third month. ..Source.. by Judy Thpiazza



Inmate Death/Riot, Stabbings in California

11-14-2007 California:

Civil Detainee's Death Comes Amid Allegations That Coalinga State Hospital Falls Dangerously Short In Medical Care

Coalinga State Hospital, California's two year old $388 million facility for confining sex offenders after serving their entire prison sentence, is coming under renewed fire in the wake of Thursday's death of patient Frank Valado, age 45.

Valado collapsed while playing basketball with other Civil Detainees in the institution's gynmasium Thursday evening. Patients witnessing the incident said that Staff response to Valado's collapse was completely inadequate and that, effectively, he received little or no treatment after being stricken.

They reported that an officer present in the gymnasium refused to radio in an alarm, despite their requests that he do so, but instead simply left the room.
A Patient got the attention of another officer by pounding on a gymnasium window looking out onto the main courtyard. That officer then radioed the alarm that brought other staff to the scene.

One Patient began performing CPR on Valado and others present confirm that Valado partially regained consciousness. Then, a number of staff entered the gym, including two women, at least one of whom, Kathy Bryant, is a Registered Nurse. Officers ordered Michael Cheeks, who had been administering assistance to Valado, to halt his efforts and, along with the other men in the gym, to get up against the wall.

Bryant was then heard to say "I'm not putting my mouth on that man's mouth!" an apparent reference to her unwillingness to perform mouth-to-mouth resuscitation on Valado.

Patients also report that the other (unidentified) woman at the scene was searching for an oxygen tank and mask but which she was unable to locate.

A crash cart was brought into the room but it was discovered that it did not include a defibrillator. Patients later stated that they knew that there was a defibrillator on the other side of an always locked door to the gym but staff made no attempt to retrieve it or any other. Throughout this, Valado remained unassisted on the floor.


The other patients were then ordered to leave the gym and a gurney was brought in and Valado was taken to the Medical unit. However, no doctors were on duty at the time so staff then called a doctor to drive to the facility. However, before the doctor arrived at C.S.H., Frank Valado died.

The "Watch Commander" reportedly ordered all police staff to remain for the next shift, even if it were their third continuous shift on duty. The Administration is said to have been seriously concerned for the possibility of Patient anger and unrest due to the poor response by the hospital in Valado's death.

Mike St. Martin, a Detainee Spokesperson who has actively sought to bring attention to what he sees as grossly negligent standards of medical care, said he was "unsurprised" by the lack of appropriate medical response by C.S.H. Staff, stating that, since the beginning, the Institution had demonstrated an utter disregard for the well-being of Patients in the facility. "The only thing about this place that says "hospital" is the sign out in front. But that sign also says 'No emergency services available'. Well, they got that part right! We refer to this place as a 'hosprison', since that is its primary function, to act as a prison, while pretending to be a hospital.

The medical department here is a ticking time bomb with irresponsible delays, incorrect treatment, poor training, and medical care grossly deficient for an aging population. One can only hope that more people don't have to die before sweeping changes can be made".

"I wrote to Attorney General Jerry Brown in April of this year detailing the terrible medical conditions here and, to date, I have not received a response from him or his staff".

Since Executive Director Norm Kramer assumed authority in September, Dr. Peter Bresler has stepped down as Chief Physician and Surgeon while remaining as a staff physician. Patients bitterly complained of their treatment by Bresler, with one saying he had been told by Bresler that treatment for his seriously distended hernia would be considered "cosmetic" and thus not surgery that he would approve. It has been alleged that he was fired from a previous job as a result of "dropping a baby".

Deficient medical care and rubber stamped clinical assessments were amongst some of the chief complaints leading to the still ongoing strike by Civil Detainees, now in its third month. ..more.. by judythpiazza@newsblaze.com

Death at California's Civil Commitment Center: Coaling


3-5-2011 California:

Early Saturday morning, the 5th of March, 2011, Civil Detainee Victor Segovia (YouTube Video) died in California's Coalinga State Hospital. He had complained to medical staff of chest pains and difficulty breathing earlier in the evening but was left untreated and told to go to bed.

Shortly before 4:00 a.m., he collapsed on the bathroom floor and, despite attempts by other Detainees to get him the timely medical attention he desperately needed, he did not receive it and died shortly thereafter. ..Source.. by David

Suspect arrested in connection with homicide at Atascadero State Hospital



3-31-2008 California:

A patient is killed at Atascadero State Hospital. Now, another patient is charged with his death.

Here is the latest:

Sunday morning, the victim, 37 year-old, Paul Rael was found dead in his bed. A spokesperson for the hospital says he was attacked by another patient.

The suspect, 44 year-old Richard McKee, is now charged with homicide and assault with a deadly weapon.

A second victim was also badly beaten. He survived the attack.
The San Luis Obispo County Coroner's Office, the Atascadero Police Department, and the county District Attorney's Office are all assisting hospital police in their investigation.

The hospital is releasing very little information about the death.

Pasadena sex predator dies in state prison


4-17-2013 California:

Death comes just before release hearing

Carnot "No No" Lyles, a violent sexual predator convicted of raping a Pasadena woman in front of her family and later sexually molesting a 9-year-old girl, died over the weekend, just days before a scheduled hearing to decide whether he would be released from Coalinga State Hospital because of his terminal cancer.

The hearing was originally scheduled for last Friday but was postponed until this Friday after attorneys said they needed more time to gather witnesses. Lyles' attorney, Dale Rubin, filed a motion to withdraw Lyles' petition for conditional release in Los Angeles Superior Court on Tuesday.

Lyles' two victims had been fighting his release, along with Deputy District Attorney Tracy Watson.

"I think the victims are relieved," Watson said Tuesday. "They don't have to worry about him anymore. "

Lyles, 56, was among the first men committed to a state hospital under California's 1996 Sexually Violent Predator law.

The law, proposed by then-state senator Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Burbank, allows state mental health officials to civilly commit criminals who have committed at least two sexually violent crimes involving at least two victims if the prisoner has a diagnosed mental disorder that makes him a danger to the health and safety of others.

Under the Sexually Violent Predator law, prisoners can petition for conditional release if they are no longer a threat to society, such as declining health.

Rubin said he was disappointed that Watson took the issue to court rather than allowing Lyles, 56, to die with his family. He added that he thinks it is "unfortunate" that Lyles had his right to die at home taken away because he was being held at a mental hospital instead of a state prison.

Lyles sister wrote a letter to the court asking for Lyles' release so that he could spend his last days at her home, saying that Lyles had "the support of his family as he enters into his last stage of his life. "

"Even though he had already paid his debt to society, done his time, the unfortunate victims of Mr. Lyles' crimes wanted more, they wanted to hold him until his death," Rubin said. "But the only thing that was accomplished in this case was depriving Mr. Lyles of spending his last moments with his family. "


But the victims in the case said they feared Lyles would have still been a danger if he had been released, and former Pasadena Police Chief Bruce Philpott called him the "most evil person I have ever known during my 28-year career in law enforcement." Philpott added that Lyles was a skilled manipulator from an early age.

In court Friday, the girl Lyles' raped in 1988 when she was 9 told the sheriff's bailiff she was there to "make sure he stays" locked up.

Watson stood by her decision to hold a hearing on Lyles' petition for release.

"I think you definitely need oversight, you need to examine the facts and make sure the public is being protected before you make a decision like this. "

Philpott said Tuesday that he knew Lyles since he began counseling him when Lyles was in elementary school. He said Lyles was the product of a "beautiful home on north Arroyo Boulevard and both his parents were well-educated," and lamented the way Lyles' life ultimately ended.

"Carnot was an exceptionally talented kid who made some very bad decisions early in his life," Philpott said via email. "Regardless of who he became, none of this diminishes the loss of his life to his family." ..Source.. by Lauren Gold